Court of Justice of the European Union Rules Malta’s Citizenship by Investment Program Violates EU Law
In a landmark and highly controversial decision delivered by the Grand Chamber, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that Malta’s Citizenship by Investment (CBI) pathways are in direct violation of European Union law. The ruling, issued on 29 April 2025, marks a watershed moment for the investment migration sector, the internal market, and the broader conceptualization of EU citizenship.
The judgment represents a stark departure from standard legal expectations, notably clashing with the formal Opinion delivered by Advocate General Collins on 10 October 2024. In that earlier opinion, the Advocate General had recommended dismissing the European Commission’s case entirely and ordering the institution to bear the legal costs. That recommendation had effectively pointed to an overreach of EU competence in a policy domain historically reserved for sovereign member states.
However, the Grand Chamber’s final ruling completely overturned that perspective. By outlawing what the Court termed the "commercialisation" of EU citizenship, the judgment signals a decisive shift away from a more liberal framework of European citizenship. In earlier decades and established case law, EU citizenship was celebrated as a direct legal link between the individual and European authority, designed to protect citizens against external claims regarding a lack of traditional connections. With this new ruling, that particular vision of liberal citizenship at the EU level has effectively been dismantled.
Legal analysts note that this is a rare instance where the Court has taken a restrictive approach to individual status without clearly demonstrating tangible harm caused by the contested national policy. The finality of the Grand Chamber’s decision means there is no option for appeal, leaving profound implications for how member states administer their national sovereignty alongside their obligations to the broader European project.
The legal battle stems from infringement proceedings initiated by the European Commission against Malta. The Commission argued that Malta’s golden passport pathways violated Article 20 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU), which establishes that every person holding the nationality of a member state is simultaneously a citizen of the Union. According to the Commission, this article, when read in conjunction with the principle of sincere cooperation under Article 4(3) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), necessitates a "genuine link" between a member state and its nationals.
The Commission maintained that the European Union is not merely an economic trading bloc, but a political union uniting the peoples of its member states. It argued that granting citizenship through investment without verifying a substantive connection undermines mutual trust among member states, and that holding legal residence alone is insufficient to bridge that gap. To bolster its stance, the Commission invoked historical interpretations and references to the accession agreement to the European Convention on Human Rights, emphasizing that EU citizenship serves as a core raison d’être of the Union, acting as a vital expression of solidarity and mutual trust.
The Commission also pointed to landmark historical precedents, such as the Micheletti case, which dealt with Spain’s obligation to automatically recognize the Italian nationality of an Argentine citizen acquired through ancestry. The Commission framed such cases as evidence that mutual recognition packages inherently presume the existence of genuine links going beyond simple possession of formal nationality.
Malta strongly contested these assertions throughout the proceedings. The Maltese government argued that the Court was being invited to act as an indirect legislator by reviewing national legislation that falls squarely outside the powers conferred upon the European Union. Malta maintained that nationality laws remain within the exclusive competence of individual member states, that genuine link requirements are not explicitly codified in EU law, and that member states alone hold the prerogative to appraise such matters. Furthermore, Malta emphasized that the Union has never been established as a single, centralized polity, arguing that any judicial review of national legislation should be strictly limited to instances involving significant breaches of core European values or objectives.
The Court dismissed Malta’s arguments regarding exclusive national competence by pointing to its extensive body of jurisprudence. Referencing Article 3(2) of the TEU concerning the area of freedom, security, and justice, the Court detailed the bundle of rights enjoyed by EU citizens, including the right to free movement, consular protection abroad, and foundational political rights. From the existence of these collective rights, the Court deduced that the granting of member state nationality directly affects the functioning of the EU as a common legal order.
The judgment emphasized that EU citizenship is designed to be the fundamental status of member state nationals, serving as a primary expression of solidarity across borders. Consequently, the Court ruled that member states are prohibited from exercising their sovereign competencies in a manner that is manifestly incompatible with the very nature of EU citizenship, highlighting the special relationship of solidarity and good faith that underpins any nationality within the European legal framework.
While acknowledging that member states retain the formal authority to establish the criteria for this relationship, the Court insisted that such actions must strictly conform to EU law. This brought about a critical legal turning point, as the Court established a direct presumption that granting citizenship in exchange for predetermined payments or investments amounts to a manifest disregard of that foundational solidarity.
The Court explicitly stated that programs of that nature result in the commercialization of national status and, by extension, Union citizenship itself, rendering them fundamentally incompatible with the Treaties. In reviewing the specifics of Malta’s scheme, the Court scrutinized the transactional nature of the framework and noted what it considered insufficient physical presence requirements prior to naturalization when compared against ordinary naturalization procedures in the country.
Interestingly, the Court echoed the Commission’s criticism regarding Malta’s marketing practices, specifically taking issue with the fact that the Maltese program had advertised access to EU citizenship as a primary feature. Legal observers noted a tension in this reasoning, as failing to inform newly naturalized citizens of their statutory EU rights would itself constitute a violation of European law.
At the heart of the Court’s rationale was the concept of commercialization, a term repeated multiple times throughout the text of the judgment. Critics of the ruling point out that neither international legal principles—such as the Nottebohm doctrine—nor existing EU and Maltese statutory laws explicitly prohibit utilizing investment-based pathways for naturalization, leading to arguments that the ECJ has effectively introduced new law through judicial interpretation.
The full implications of Case C-181/23 are expected to reverberate across the investment migration sector and the wider legal landscape of the European Union for years to come. The complete judgment of the Grand Chamber, handed down on 29 April 2025, remains available through official European court documentation channels for further legal examination.
| Source | : | Open Passport |
| Author | : | Lina Irawan |
| Editor | : | Open Passport Editorial Team |
