Navigating the AI Shift: Gallagher Benefits Leader on Governance, Trust, and What Plan Sponsors Must Fix First
Artificial intelligence is arriving in employer-sponsored benefits programs faster than most human resources teams were prepared to handle, and the gap between deploying a technology tool and earning employees’ genuine trust in it is proving increasingly costly for organizations.
As the 2026 and 2027 open enrollment season gets underway, Robby White, the U.S. benefits line leader at Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. based in Houston, observes that the conversation among plan sponsors has fundamentally changed. HR leaders are no longer asking whether they should incorporate artificial intelligence into their benefits programs. Instead, they are urgently asking whether they possess the proper governance, the necessary data quality, and the employee trust required to make those digital tools deliver real, measurable outcomes.
The sheer scale of recent adoption makes that question exceptionally pressing for organizations of all sizes. According to the Society for Human Resource Management’s (SHRM) 2026 Employee Benefits Survey, employer-sponsored subscriptions to artificial intelligence tools surged dramatically from 16 percent in 2025 to 33 percent in 2026, marking the largest single-year increase ever recorded by the organization. However, this rapid deployment is running well ahead of operational execution and strategic planning.
Supporting this trend, the WTW 2026 AI Use in Health and Benefits Survey—which polled 312 employers covering approximately 4.6 million U.S. employees—found that only 20 percent of employers report actively operationalizing artificial intelligence in their benefits programs today. Meanwhile, a substantial 72 percent of employers plan to do so within the next two years. This delta between ambition and execution highlights a critical vulnerability in how companies are approaching technological modernization within their benefits portfolios.
The Three Problems HR Is Trying to Solve
White explains that human resources leaders heading into the 2026 and 2027 open enrollment season find themselves under immense pressure on three distinct yet deeply interconnected fronts. These include spiraling healthcare and pharmacy costs, an overloaded human resources function constantly managing routine and repetitive employee queries, and a workforce that frequently does not fully understand or effectively utilize the valuable benefits already available to them.
"The conversation has moved beyond using AI simply to automate administrative work," White said. "Employees are weighing healthcare costs, prescription drug exposure, provider access, mental health resources, voluntary benefits, and financial wellbeing support, often without feeling confident that they understand the tradeoffs. AI can help translate that complexity into more personalized and actionable guidance based on factors such as life stage, family circumstances, affordability concerns, and prior utilization."
For the human resources function specifically, White notes that the primary value proposition is gaining a clearer, more comprehensive view of how the entire benefits portfolio is performing across the enterprise.
"AI can support benefits communications, workforce analytics, and post-enrollment analysis while helping employers identify gaps in employee understanding and evaluate how programs interact across a fragmented vendor ecosystem," he said. "Over time, that insight can help HR leaders make more informed decisions about program design, communications, and investment."
The broader objective, he adds, is to fundamentally improve how existing benefits are understood and utilized, reduce unnecessary utilization and financial waste, and direct employees toward higher-value resources without arbitrarily adding brand-new programs that workers simply cannot navigate. This strategic reframe matters immensely for HR leaders who have spent years expanding benefit offerings, only to find that employee utilization rates remain disappointing.
What HR Leaders Are Getting Wrong on AI
Despite the clear potential for modernization, White identifies several critical failures he sees most frequently among employers moving rapidly into artificial intelligence-enabled benefits. The first misstep is treating artificial intelligence adoption strictly as a technology implementation project rather than viewing it as a comprehensive change-management and trust-building effort.
"There’s also an important distinction between deploying AI and earning employees’ trust in it," he said. "Employers may be moving quickly to operationalize the technology, but employees will not automatically use an AI-enabled tool simply because it is available. Employees need to understand and trust how AI is being used in the benefits process."
He points to the deeply personal and sensitive nature of healthcare and benefits decisions as the primary reason why trust must be built deliberately and well in advance. Employees naturally want to know what specific information is being collected, who is authorized to access it, how recommendations are generated, and critically, whether artificial intelligence is simply advising them or actually making decisions on their behalf. Furthermore, workers may vary significantly in their digital comfort levels, health literacy, and baseline confidence when navigating complex healthcare and benefits systems. HR teams that treat the technology rollout as a routine communications exercise—rather than a genuine shift in how employees experience their benefits—will likely find that adoption rates fall well short of their initial projections.
The second common failure is a matter of timing.

"Another mistake is waiting until enrollment begins to explain the technology," White said. "Employers should test systems well in advance, clearly communicate their privacy practices, prepare HR teams and vendors with consistent messaging, and give employees a straightforward explanation of what AI will and will not do."
A third distinct risk White flags is the temptation to adopt new capabilities purely for their own sake, driven by marketing hype rather than organizational need.
"One common mistake is adopting a capability because it is marketed as AI without determining whether it solves a meaningful problem," he said. "A disconnected tool can add complexity to an already fragmented benefits ecosystem rather than simplifying it. Poor-quality or fragmented data can also weaken recommendations and quickly undermine employee trust."
What Responsible AI Governance Looks Like for Plan Sponsors
White is precise about what responsible deployment requires from HR leaders who want to avoid these common pitfalls. It starts, he emphasizes, with robust data governance, clearly defined privacy protections, and absolute accountability before any tool is allowed to go live across the workforce.
"Employers need to understand what information an AI-enabled tool uses, how that information is collected and stored, who is authorized to access it, and how recommendations are generated," White said. "Employees should also have meaningful control over their information and confidence that it is being used only for its intended purpose."
That governance framework must naturally extend to rigorous vendor oversight. Because benefits vendors routinely handle sensitive health, financial, and personal employee information, HR leaders need to scrutinize these third-party relationships thoroughly. This requires examining security and compliance practices, data ownership policies, permitted uses of analytics, breach-response responsibilities, and protocols detailing how data will be returned or securely destroyed when a contract eventually terminates. White notes that this critical responsibility cannot be delegated entirely to procurement or IT departments; the decisions sit squarely within the people function.
"From a compliance and fiduciary perspective, employers should treat AI as part of the broader benefits governance framework, not as a stand-alone technology purchase," White said. "Tools should be evaluated for data quality, accuracy, integration, employee outcomes, and their ability to support appropriate oversight."
The U.S. Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) establishes the strict fiduciary framework under which employer-sponsored plans must evaluate vendor relationships and data stewardship. HR leaders governing artificial intelligence tools in employee benefits are operating directly within those established legal and regulatory obligations.
Making AI Work for Employees Year-Round
Beyond compliance and governance frameworks, White suggests that the most meaningful shift for human resources leaders to target is moving artificial intelligence out of the restrictive annual enrollment window and into a continuous, year-round support model. This approach connects employees to the right resource, provider, or benefit at the exact moment they actually need it in their daily lives.
"Employees should have 24/7 access to the right resources and information at the moment they need them, with a clear path to human support," White said. "That includes benefit counsellors who are available virtually or by phone when an employee wants help interpreting options, validating guidance, or working through a more complex decision."
For employees, the tangible change is that benefits decisions can become significantly more personalized and far less overwhelming. Rather than presenting every worker with the exact same standardized catalog of insurance plans and ancillary programs, artificial intelligence-enabled guidance can surface options that are far more relevant to an individual’s unique circumstances. This includes explaining complex tradeoffs involving cost sharing, coverage limits, prescription drug exposure, and provider access in clear, plain language.
"AI can help employees compare plans, estimate costs, understand coverage differences, and identify high-quality or lower-cost care alternatives," White said. "It can also connect them with resources such as mental health support, chronic-condition programs, voluntary benefits, and financial wellbeing tools."
The ultimate goal, White makes clear, is not to push employees toward automated technology for its own sake. Rather, it is to create an operational experience in which artificial intelligence is genuinely useful, completely transparent, and always backed by human expertise—an experience that forward-thinking HR leaders design, govern, and remain fully accountable for delivering.
| Source | : | Open Passport |
| Author | : | Nana |
| Editor | : | Open Passport Editorial Team |
